My advice: everyone participating should review the rules. It will hopefully cut back the need for so many warnings and penalties, and reduce the "oh I must have missed that rule" statement.......
IMO reports filed by people not involved in a particular incident can cause unnecessary turmoil between participants, and could also end up creating an excessive amount of frivolus reports.
And considering how many reports you and menantoll have had to review, you should understand how the admins would want to keep it to a minimum...